Are Mules The Most Underrated Footwear? We Wore Them For A Week To Find Out

Fashion has its favourites. Every era sees certain footwear trends take the spotlight, chunky sneakers, sky-high heels, minimalist sandals, and combat boots have all had their moments. Yet, one type of shoe has remained in the background, quietly sophisticated but never the centre of attention: the mule.

With their backless design and effortlessly chic appeal, mules are a curious blend of casual ease and refined style. They can be flat or heeled, pointed or rounded, leather or suede, offering something for everyone. But despite this versatility, they often remain an afterthought in most wardrobes.

The question is: Why? Are they simply too understated, or have they been unfairly overlooked? To find out, a pair of mules was worn exclusively for a full seven days, at work, on errands, to social events, and even on a casual night out. The goal was simple: assess their style, comfort, practicality and overall wearability.

Here's what the experiment revealed.

Are Mules Underrated Footwear? We Wore Them For A Week To Find Out; Photo Credit: Pexels

1. First Impressions: A Fuss-Free Favourite?

The first moment of slipping into mules is one of quiet satisfaction. There's no struggle with laces, buckles, or zippers, just an effortless glide of the foot into place. It's the footwear equivalent of sinking into a cosy chair after a long day.

However, there were some initial concerns. Would they feel secure? Would they slip off while walking? Would they look too safe or uninspiring?

Within the first few hours, those concerns faded. The structured fit provided enough grip to keep the shoe in place, while the backless design allowed for a refreshing sense of freedom. The toe area offered enough space without feeling loose, creating a natural balance between comfort and support.

Aesthetically, they blended into different outfits with ease. Paired with tailored trousers, they looked refined. Styled with jeans, they added an effortless touch. Worn with a flowing dress, they completed the look with understated elegance.

First impressions? A strong start.

2. Comfort Level: Like Slippers, But Better?

Comfort is often the deciding factor when choosing footwear, and mules exceeded expectations. The padded insoles and soft material made walking feel surprisingly luxurious, like wearing stylish house slippers, but with proper support.

There's a certain weightlessness to them. Unlike heavy boots or structured heels, mules feel light on the feet, making them ideal for all-day wear. There was no need for a painful breaking-in period, no pinched toes, and no blisters, something that's hard to come by in a new pair of shoes.

However, material choice plays a big role. Leather and suede mules adapt to the foot over time, creating a custom fit, whereas synthetic versions lack breathability and can feel stiff. A good-quality pair made all the difference, providing the right mix of flexibility and durability.

By the end of the day, one thing was certain: mules were not just stylish, they were a dream to wear.

3. Versatility: Can Mules Handle A Full Week Of Wear?

The ultimate test of any shoe is its ability to adapt to different occasions. Could mules seamlessly transition from work to casual outings, dinner dates, and everything in between?

• Workwear:

In a professional setting, mules proved to be a refined choice. A pointed-toe mule in neutral tones paired well with tailored trousers and a structured blouse, creating an effortlessly polished look. Unlike heels, they offered sophistication without sacrificing comfort, a major plus for long office hours.

• Casual Outings:

Running errands in mules felt incredibly easy. They slipped on quickly, added a touch of elegance to a simple jeans-and-t-shirt combo, and were comfortable enough for a relaxed day out. Unlike trainers, they offered a more put-together look without any extra effort.

• Evening Wear:

For a night out, a heeled mule delivered just the right amount of glamour. Unlike traditional heels, they were much more forgiving on the feet, making them an excellent choice for those who love a dressed-up look without the pain of stilettos.

The only scenario where they fell short? High-intensity activities. Mules aren't built for long walks, running, or activities that require extra grip. But for everyday wear, they passed the versatility test with flying colours.

Are Mules Underrated Footwear? We Wore Them For A Week To Find Out; Photo Credit: Pexels

4. Style Factor: Subtle Chic Or Just Plain Safe?

Footwear can make or break an outfit, and mules sit somewhere between effortless and elevated. They don't scream for attention like statement heels, but they also don't blend into the background like standard flats. Instead, they offer a quiet sophistication, like the best-dressed person in the room who doesn't need to try too hard.

A sleek black mule worked beautifully as a wardrobe staple, but experimenting with different styles brought an exciting twist. A metallic finish added a contemporary edge, while embroidered designs created a more bohemian feel. A bold red mule, on the other hand, made a strong fashion statement without being overpowering.

By midweek, it was clear: mules were far from boring. They were the secret weapon for making an outfit feel effortlessly stylish.

5. Practicality: A Daily Essential Or Just A Trend?

Mules shine in their sheer convenience. The slip-on design makes them the ideal shoe for those in a rush, no buckles to fasten, no laces to tie. Whether heading out for a quick coffee run or dashing to a last-minute meeting, they became the go-to choice.

That being said, they do require some adjustment when walking. Unlike secure lace-ups, mules have a slight tendency to ‘flap' if the walking pace is too quick. Slowing down and walking with a more deliberate step solved this issue, but it's something to be mindful of.

Durability-wise, a well-made pair held up exceptionally well throughout the week, showing minimal signs of wear. They didn't stretch out or lose their shape, proving that a quality pair can go the distance.

6. Weather Considerations: A Seasonal Shoe?

Mules are the ultimate transitional shoe, perfect for spring and autumn. On warm days, they feel airy and breathable, making them an excellent alternative to closed-toe shoes.

However, they aren't built for extreme weather. When temperatures dropped, the open-heel design meant chilly feet, and during a surprise rain shower, they weren't the most practical choice. While some waterproof options exist, they don't offer the same versatility as boots or trainers in wet conditions.

For mild weather, mules are an unbeatable choice. But for colder months, they're best paired with thick socks indoors or swapped out for something more winter-friendly.

7. The Confidence Boost: The Unexpected Perk

Shoes have a way of influencing confidence. A great pair of heels can make someone feel powerful, while an uncomfortable pair of flats can ruin an entire day. Mules, surprisingly, came with their own confidence boost.

Perhaps it was their effortless style or the way they made any outfit feel more polished. Maybe it was the comfort factor allowing for an easy, natural stride. Whatever the reason, they brought a sense of refined ease, like the feeling of walking into a room knowing you're effortlessly put together.

This wasn't expected, but it became one of the biggest takeaways from the week-long experiment.

8. The Final Verdict: Are Mules Worth The Hype?

After seven days of exclusively wearing mules, the conclusion was clear: they are one of the most underrated footwear choices. They offer a rare combination of style, comfort, and practicality, perfect for those who value effortless elegance. Their versatility makes them suitable for a range of occasions, and their slip-on design is a game-changer for convenience. Of course, they aren't perfect. They don't handle extreme weather well, and they require a slightly adjusted walking style. But for everyday wear? They are nothing short of brilliant. Mules may not always steal the spotlight, but they deserve a place in every wardrobe. And once worn, it's hard to go back.

Are Mules Underrated Footwear? We Wore Them For A Week To Find Out; Photo Credit: Pexels

Explore Products Related To This Article 

1. XE Looks Embellished Block Heel Mules

2. Metro Grey Embellished Comfort Mules

3. Metro Printed Block Heel Mules

4. CHINRAAG Block Heel Mules

5. Mast & Harbour Green Textured Pointed Toe Kitten Heel P

6. Mochi Blue Comfort Mules

7. Metro Embellished Block Mules

8. Shezone Women Embellishment Ethnic Block Mules

After a full week of wearing mules, the results were undeniable, they are, without question, one of the most overlooked yet highly practical footwear choices. Their effortless slip-on design, surprising comfort, and adaptability make them a must-have for those who appreciate both style and convenience. Mules bridge the gap between casual and sophisticated, making them suitable for a range of occasions. They elevate an everyday outfit without feeling overdressed, and they offer the refinement of heels without the discomfort. While they aren't built for extreme weather or high-impact activities, they excel in day-to-day wear, proving to be a reliable wardrobe staple.

Perhaps the most unexpected discovery was the confidence boost they provided. There's something about their sleek, unfussy design that makes an outfit feel instantly more polished, without the effort of more complicated footwear choices. So, are mules the most underrated footwear? Absolutely. They may not always be in the spotlight, but once discovered, they quickly become a go-to favourite. One week of wearing them was enough to realise: mules aren't just a trend, they're a timeless essential worth investing in.

Disclaimer: The images used in this article are for illustration purpose only. They may not be an exact representation of the products, categories and brands listed in this article.